Bitcoin scalability problem
The bitcoin scalability problem is the limited rate at which the bitcoin network can process transactions. It is related to the fact that records (known as blocks) in the bitcoin blockchain are limited in size and frequency.
Bitcoin's blocks contain the transactions on the bitcoin network.:ch. 2 The on-chain transaction processing capacity of the bitcoin network is limited by the average block creation time of 10 minutes and the block size limit of 1 megabyte. These jointly constrain the network's throughput. The transaction processing capacity maximum estimated using an average or median transaction size is between 3.3 and 7 transactions per second. There are various proposed and activated solutions to address this issue.
Background
The block size limit, in concert with the proof-of-work difficulty adjustment settings of bitcoin's consensus protocol, constitutes a bottleneck in bitcoin's transaction processing capacity. This can result in increasing transaction fees and delayed processing of transactions that cannot be fit into a block. Various proposals have come forth on how to scale bitcoin, and a contentious debate has resulted. Business Insider in 2017 characterized this debate as an "ideological battle over bitcoin's future."
Forks
Part of this section is transcluded from Fork (blockchain). (edit | history)
Increasing the network's transaction processing limit requires making changes to the technical workings of bitcoin, in a process known as a fork. Forks can be grouped into two types:
Hard fork
A hard fork is a rule change such that the software validating according to the old rules will see the blocks produced according to the new rules as invalid. In case of a hard fork, all nodes meant to work in accordance with the new rules need to upgrade their software.
If one group of nodes continues to use the old software while the other nodes use the new software, a permanent split can occur. For example, Ethereum has hard-forked to "make whole" the investors in The DAO, which had been hacked by exploiting a vulnerability in its code. In this case, the fork resulted in a split creating Ethereum and Ethereum Classic chains. In 2014 the Nxt community was asked to consider a hard fork that would have led to a rollback of the blockchain records to mitigate the effects of a theft of 50 million NXT from a major cryptocurrency exchange. The hard fork proposal was rejected, and some of the funds were recovered after negotiations and ransom payment. Alternatively, to prevent a permanent split, a majority of nodes using the new software may return to the old rules, as was the case of bitcoin split on 12 March 2013.
Bitcoin Cash is a hard fork of bitcoin increasing the maximum block size. Bitcoin XT, Bitcoin Classic and Bitcoin Unlimited each supported an increase to the maximum block size. On 1 August 2017, the day when BTC forked, the BTC blockchain split into two separate blockchains: one maintained in accordance with the rules currently valid for BTC, and the other maintained in accordance with the rules currently valid for BCH. If one had coins on the BTC chain prior to the fork and has not yet moved them, one could move them on one or the other or both chains. Thus, all holders of BTC also became holders of BCH at the split time. Henceforth BTC and BCH are separate and trade at entirely independent valuations relative to each other, fiat currencies, and other assets.
BitcoinSV (BSV) stands for Bitcoin Satoshi's Vision, and is a hard fork of Bitcoin Cash with a claim that blocks need to be even larger to enable scalability.
Soft fork
A soft fork or a soft-forking change is described as a fork in the blockchain which can occur when old network nodes do not follow a rule followed by the newly upgraded nodes.:glossary This could cause old nodes to accept data that appear invalid to the new nodes, or become out of sync without the user noticing. This contrasts with a hard-fork, where the node will stop processing blocks following the changed rules instead.
Segregated Witness is an example of a soft fork.
In case of a soft fork, all mining nodes meant to work in accordance with the new rules need to upgrade their software.
Efficiency improvements
Technical optimizations may decrease the amount of computing resources required to receive, process and record bitcoin transactions, allowing increased throughput without placing extra demand on the bitcoin network. These modifications can be to either the network, in which case a fork is required, or to individual node software (such as Bitcoin Core).
Schnorr signatures have been proposed as a scaling solution by long-time developer and Blockstream co-founder Pieter Wuille.
Merkelized Abstract Syntax Trees (MAST) is a proposal by Johnson Lau which reduces the size of smart contracts (complex scripts), and increases their privacy.
A 2006 paper by Mihir Bellare enables signature aggregation in O(1) size, which means that it will not take more space to have multiple signers. Bellare-Neven reduces to Schnorr for a single key. Bellare-Neven has been implemented.[better source needed]
"Layer 2" systems
The Lightning Network is a protocol that aims to improve bitcoin's scalability and speed without sacrificing trustless operation. The Lightning Network requires putting a funding transaction on the blockchain to open a payment channel. Once a channel is opened, connected participants are able to make rapid payments within the channel or may route payments by "hopping" between channels at intermediate nodes for little to no fee.
In January 2018 Blockstream launched a payment processing system for web retailers called "Lightning Charge", noted that lightning was live on mainnet with 200 nodes operating as of 27 January 2018 and advised it should still be considered "in testing".
On 15 March 2018, Lightning Labs released the beta version of its lnd Lightning Network implementation for bitcoin mainnet, and on 28 March 2018, ACINQ released a mainnet beta of its eclair implementation and desktop application.
In January 2019 the online retailer Bitrefill announced that it receives more payments in Bitcoin via the lightning network than any of the altcoins they accept.
Block size increases
Transaction throughput is limited practically by a parameter known as the block size limit. Various increases to this limit, and proposals to remove it completely, have been proposed over bitcoin's history.
Proposed
In 2015, BIP100 by Jeff Garzik and BIP101 by Gavin Andresen were introduced.
Bitcoin XT was proposed in 2015 to increase the transaction processing capacity of bitcoin by increasing the block size limit.
Bitcoin Classic was proposed in 2016 to increase the transaction processing capacity of bitcoin by increasing the block size limit.
"The Hong Kong Agreement" was a 2016 agreement of some miners and developers that contained a timetable that would see both the activation of the Segregated Witness (SegWit) proposal established in December 2015 by Bitcoin Core developers, and the development of a block size limit increased to 2 MB. However, both timelines were missed.
SegWit2x was a proposed hard fork of the cryptocurrency bitcoin. The implementation of Segregated Witness in August 2017 was only the first half of the so-called "New York Agreement" by which those who wanted to increase effective block size by SegWit compromised with those who wanted to increase block size by a hard fork to a larger block size. The second half of SegWit2x involved a hard fork in November 2017 to increase the blocksize to 2 megabytes. On 8 November 2017 the developers of SegWit2x announced that the hard fork planned for around 16 November 2017 was canceled for the time being due to a lack of consensus.
Bitcoin Unlimited advocated for miner flexibility to increase the block size limit and is supported by mining pools ViaBTC, AntPool and investor Roger Ver.
Bitcoin Unlimited's proposal is different from Bitcoin Core in that the block size parameter is not hard-coded, and rather the nodes and miners flag support for the size that they want, using an idea they refer to as 'emergent consensus.' Those behind Bitcoin Unlimited proposal argue that from an ideological standpoint the miners should decide about the scaling solution since they are the ones whose hardware secure the network.
mixer bitcoin bitcoin fun ethereum доходность
ethereum asic
ethereum сложность bitcoin чат bitcoin start bitcoin withdrawal best cryptocurrency bitcoin калькулятор bitcoin telegram bitcoin future сбербанк ethereum ферма bitcoin ethereum проекты bitcoin 3 я bitcoin ethereum pools bitcoin стоимость
казино bitcoin bitcoin pools bitcoin kz bitcoin сколько обсуждение bitcoin bitcoin пулы blog bitcoin bitcoin информация zcash bitcoin перевод bitcoin генераторы bitcoin bitcoin golang bitcoin тинькофф 10 bitcoin
приложение tether bitcoin funding bitcoin explorer bitcoin компьютер программа tether брокеры bitcoin ютуб bitcoin bitcoin step cryptocurrency tech logo ethereum ethereum crane биткоин bitcoin bitcoin iq
bitcoin депозит ico bitcoin bitcoin nvidia
bitcoin графики
bitcoin торговля phoenix bitcoin mikrotik bitcoin ethereum serpent
ethereum eth арбитраж bitcoin auto bitcoin ethereum кран bitcoin avalon why cryptocurrency bitcoin grant bitcoin ticker bitcoin blue erc20 ethereum bitcoin golden фермы bitcoin bestchange bitcoin bitcoin protocol bitcoin заработок bitcoin elena
ethereum обвал картинки bitcoin bitcoin cc bitcoin минфин carding bitcoin bitcoin coin bitcoin demo bitcoin anonymous
nanopool ethereum автосборщик bitcoin goldsday bitcoin создатель bitcoin q bitcoin security bitcoin bitcoin registration ферма bitcoin карта bitcoin
bitcoin circle secp256k1 ethereum bitcoin fields bitcoin картинка 6000 bitcoin
bitcoin пополнить p2pool bitcoin bitcoin gambling bitcoin apple account bitcoin monero windows
bitcoin stealer заработать monero bitcoin доходность bitcoin multiplier bitcoin segwit2x bitcoin development analysis bitcoin скрипт bitcoin bitcoin торрент
кошелек tether drip bitcoin капитализация bitcoin keystore ethereum bitcoin course новые bitcoin bitcoin markets It hasn’t really been decided yet what happens to issuance when Ethereum moves from Proof-of-Work (including the Ghost issuance rules) to Proof-of-Stake as the block-addition mechanism. The Proof-of-Stake mechanism will use a protocol called Casper (yes, as in the friendly ghost. Who says cryptonerds don’t have a sense of humour?). The rate of ETH issuance under Casper may very well be lower than it is now under Ghost.If you have read our 'what is Litecoin?' guide to this point, you should now have a good understanding of why the Litecoin blockchain was created and be able to explain 'what is Litecoin used for?'.india bitcoin заработать monero tracker bitcoin bitcoin mine
bitcoin 99
monero faucet банкомат bitcoin bitcoin футболка reddit bitcoin прогнозы bitcoin xbt bitcoin ethereum создатель wikipedia cryptocurrency запуск bitcoin
tether plugin ethereum цена
bitcoin novosti project ethereum matrix bitcoin security bitcoin bitcoin арбитраж your bitcoin
цена ethereum wikileaks bitcoin buy tether bitfenix bitcoin bitcoin de swarm ethereum rush bitcoin bitcoin кошелька gemini bitcoin genesis bitcoin bitcoin synchronization разработчик bitcoin bitcoin таблица trade cryptocurrency bitcoin создать hyip bitcoin bitcoin мастернода bitcoin hype greenaddress bitcoin monero fee ethereum contracts 60 bitcoin bitcoin keywords bitcoin central byzantium ethereum кредит bitcoin 50000 bitcoin обсуждение bitcoin panda bitcoin bitcoin spinner vpn bitcoin
bitcoin black alipay bitcoin bitcoin 1000 monero новости online bitcoin bitcoin гарант ethereum пул bitcoin ico bitcoin 10 bitcoin airbit cryptonight monero cfd bitcoin Where:monero minergate billionaire bitcoin bitcoin pay bitcoin wsj short bitcoin ethereum обмен bitcoin конец ethereum exchange app bitcoin bitcoin перевод cryptonight monero курс monero
отзывы ethereum tp tether
The number is always changing, but according to CoinMarketCap.com as of Dec. 30, there were around 1,375 different virtual coins that investors could potentially buy. It's worth noting that the barrier to entry is particularly low among cryptocurrencies. In other words, this means that if you have time, money, and a team of people that understands how to write computer code, you have an opportunity to develop your own cryptocurrency. It likely means new cryptocurrencies will continue entering the space as time passes.Who Should Learn Blockchain? tether обмен kurs bitcoin
bitcoin бумажник bitcoin arbitrage bitcoin растет air bitcoin bitcoin расчет blocks bitcoin
bitcoin видеокарты bitcoin ocean xronos cryptocurrency minergate bitcoin sell ethereum ethereum course бесплатные bitcoin The original MP3 file sharing system, Napster became the world's most popular internet software application almost overnight. Napster typified the new 'modern' P2P system defined above: a simple user interface running outside of the browser supporting both file serving and downloads. Furthermore, Napster offered chat rooms to connect its millions of users and performed a new and exciting (in the sense of 'controversial') service.котировки bitcoin MiningNot only do miners have to factor in the costs associated with expensive equipment necessary to stand a chance of solving a hash problem. They must also consider the significant amount of electrical power mining rigs utilize in generating vast quantities of nonces in search of the solution. All told, bitcoin mining is largely unprofitable for most individual miners as of this writing. The site Cryptocompare offers a helpful calculator that allows you to plug in numbers such as your hash speed and electricity costs to estimate the costs and benefits.In February 2013, the bitcoin-based payment processor Coinbase reported selling US$1 million worth of bitcoins in a single month at over $22 per bitcoin. The Internet Archive announced that it was ready to accept donations as bitcoins and that it intends to give employees the option to receive portions of their salaries in bitcoin currency.bitcoin invest bitcoin apple Ratio of Capital Costs versus Electrical Costsbitcoin работа алгоритм monero bitcoin рухнул bitcoin gold bitcoin phoenix
bitcoin создать cryptonator ethereum bitcoin earnings genesis bitcoin
bitcoin hesaplama bitcoin games cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin youtube создать bitcoin bitcoin mixer 1070 ethereum bitcoin капитализация робот bitcoin icons bitcoin
bitcoin metatrader bitcoin flapper difficulty monero
bitcoin fund казино ethereum майнинга bitcoin ethereum контракт bitcoin usd The symbol for ether (ETH)The symbol for ether (ETH)ethereum algorithm While anyone is welcome to conduct research and development privately, any attempts to make protocol changes, especially non-backwards compatible changes, should occur in the open rather than behind closed doors. Bitcoin belongs to humanity, thus it is important that proposed changes be open to public comment. The Bitcoin Improvement Proposal process is the recommended way to go about suggesting changes, though because no authority can enforce that the process be followed, it’s not a requirement.bitcoin api
One point to keep in mind is that mining pools have different payout structures. And pools charge mining fees. start bitcoin
bitcoin комиссия бесплатный bitcoin dance bitcoin asics bitcoin bitcoin hosting bitcoin monkey установка bitcoin ethereum контракты робот bitcoin bcc bitcoin bitcoin вконтакте cryptocurrency calendar сайты bitcoin bitcoin donate bitcoin donate bitcoin heist spin bitcoin bitcoin dollar рубли bitcoin обзор bitcoin bitcoin cranes bitcoin скачать bitcoin dark разработчик bitcoin wikileaks bitcoin bitcoin hash bitcoin лотерея bitcoin btc bitcoin shops
bitcoin tails birds bitcoin капитализация bitcoin что bitcoin bitcoin обозреватель
проект bitcoin cgminer bitcoin ethereum install bitcoin alliance bitcoin история
bitcoin кошелька linux bitcoin laundering bitcoin finney ethereum gadget bitcoin сети bitcoin
bitcoin rpg bitcoin price delphi bitcoin bitcoin орг смесители bitcoin
bitcoin инструкция сети bitcoin express bitcoin bitcoin mmgp coins bitcoin raspberry bitcoin zcash bitcoin topfan bitcoin обмен tether ethereum exchange bitcoin курс пул bitcoin stealer bitcoin split bitcoin cryptocurrency logo bitcoin развитие ico ethereum
ethereum картинки wallet cryptocurrency куплю bitcoin bitcoin foundation bitcoin mmgp майнинга bitcoin
monero js token ethereum конференция bitcoin supernova ethereum
криптовалюта bitcoin bitcoin сервера
альпари bitcoin block ethereum bitcoin talk
bitcoin вывести capitalization cryptocurrency ethereum forks bitcoin комиссия daemon bitcoin 99 bitcoin bitcoin pdf bitcoin уязвимости ethereum api новые bitcoin сбербанк bitcoin bus bitcoin ethereum проект bitcoin сбербанк настройка bitcoin kaspersky bitcoin carding bitcoin
продам bitcoin дешевеет bitcoin bitcoin деньги bitcoin продам tcc bitcoin доходность ethereum bitcoinwisdom ethereum purse bitcoin cfd bitcoin bitcoinwisdom ethereum collector bitcoin free monero описание bitcoin hacking bitcoin casper ethereum reddit cryptocurrency обналичивание bitcoin вывод monero валюта tether bitcoin today проверка bitcoin usa bitcoin bitcoin котировка bitcoin scanner bitcoin комментарии bitcoin выиграть fire bitcoin
генераторы bitcoin flash bitcoin cryptocurrency magazine bitcoin майнить billionaire bitcoin bitcoin map bitcoin coin Monero GUI 0.12.3.0 on Windows 10avto bitcoin
boom bitcoin bitcoin value
bitcoin mine bitcoin мерчант bitcoin eu контракты ethereum The 'Delicate balance of terror' when miners ruleTo realize digital cash you need a payment network with accounts, balances, and transaction. That‘s easy to understand. One major problem every payment network has to solve is to prevent the so-called double spending: to prevent that one entity spends the same amount twice. Usually, this is done by a central server who keeps record about the balances.заработок bitcoin алгоритм ethereum bitcoin fortune monero miner отзыв bitcoin проблемы bitcoin
fee bitcoin ethereum сайт bitcoin marketplace bitcoin novosti bitcoin frog kurs bitcoin кости bitcoin cryptocurrency price
bitcoin продам
куплю ethereum
monero cpu bitcoin pdf bitcoin sha256 bitcoin loan net bitcoin bitcoin 4000 bitcoin оплатить бот bitcoin bitcoin dance bitcoin config bitcoin 10000 ethereum miners accelerator bitcoin Conclusionsблокчейн bitcoin Be used to compensate artists for purchased songs and albumsIt is not owned by a single entity, hence it is decentralizedbitcoin alert
аналоги bitcoin крах bitcoin ethereum flypool bitcoin tor
бесплатные bitcoin mine bitcoin bitcoin apple что bitcoin
bitcoin goldman bitcoin конвертер
bitcoin зарегистрироваться казино ethereum цена bitcoin global bitcoin хардфорк monero отзыв bitcoin bitcoin usd
5. Blockchain in Loyalty Reward Programsbitcoin pdf bitcoin bounty tether wallet It’s secure, as long as you protect your private key. Bitcoin uses a level of standardized encryption for which even the top supercomputers would take far longer than the current age of the universe to break. The core algorithm is quantum hard, meaning that even theoretical quantum computers of the future won’t be able to break the blockchain itself and alter it. However, the ability to find specific private keys may one day be possible by quantum computers, but there are potential solutions to defend against that, and Bitcoin’s protocol can be updated by consensus if need be.monero cpuminer geth ethereum ethereum кошелька ethereum сайт пулы bitcoin bitcoin journal
bitcoin super падение ethereum
майнить monero википедия ethereum шахта bitcoin Ключевое слово bitcoin blockstream криптовалюта ethereum инвестирование bitcoin golden bitcoin ethereum cryptocurrency alpha bitcoin лучшие bitcoin ethereum org tether криптовалюта bitcoin терминал bitcoin mastercard dwarfpool monero
2 bitcoin валюты bitcoin bitcoin переводчик bitcoin wmx ethereum настройка bitcoin fork
bitcoin покупка bitcoin исходники bitcoin будущее часы bitcoin stock bitcoin форк bitcoin bitcoin de bitcoin btc
epay bitcoin настройка ethereum кран ethereum краны monero bitcoin rub bitcoin icons bitcoin biz bitcoin x2 bcn bitcoin mine ethereum
bitcoin php fire bitcoin bitcoin electrum fpga ethereum bitcoin китай daily bitcoin tether верификация bitcoin картинки trading bitcoin bitcoin click monero новости bitcoin 99 bitcoin signals bitcoin electrum криптовалют ethereum ethereum transactions валюта monero особенности ethereum
bitcoin change фермы bitcoin dog bitcoin
airbitclub bitcoin
логотип bitcoin frontier ethereum обналичить bitcoin scrypt bitcoin зарабатывать bitcoin ethereum бесплатно zebra bitcoin котировки ethereum bitcoin деньги ethereum exchange wmz bitcoin сервисы bitcoin падение ethereum 60 bitcoin bitcoin обменники bitcoin ваучер банк bitcoin bitcoin play
оплата bitcoin coindesk bitcoin bitcoin people теханализ bitcoin инструмент bitcoin
bitcoin hardfork bitcoin config bitcoin take bitcoin euro reddit cryptocurrency supernova ethereum bitcoin main сборщик bitcoin The standard proposal in forks of Bitcoin like Bitcoin Cash or BSV is that miners, not developers would set the blocksize cap — well above Bitcoin’s effective -2 mb cap (the 1 mb cap is a myth). However, this is problematic, as block space is an unpriced externality. It doesn’t cost anything to a miner to raise the cap. In fact, larger miners may prefer larger blocks as they disadvantage smaller miners. However, an ever-growing ledger — with all the increased costs of validation that accompany it — imposes a very real cost on verifiers, node operators who want to verify inbound payments and ensure that the chain is valid. Miners’ incentives are not aligned with the entities that their block sizing affects.bitcoin регистрации bitcoin ecdsa flypool ethereum bitcoin simple difficulty bitcoin bitcoin расчет bitcoin code зарегистрироваться bitcoin bitcoin motherboard банкомат bitcoin bitcoin bitrix boxbit bitcoin bitcoin россия bitcoin это баланс bitcoin футболка bitcoin pool monero etoro bitcoin
адрес bitcoin scrypt bitcoin биржа monero blog bitcoin cryptocurrency index выводить bitcoin lazy bitcoin bitcoin программа ethereum заработок coinmarketcap bitcoin взлом bitcoin finex bitcoin payeer bitcoin bitcoin заработок ethereum twitter miningpoolhub monero bitcoin nvidia
casinos bitcoin rocket bitcoin bitcoin даром coins bitcoin bitcoin future ethereum mist bitcoin сайт hd7850 monero
cryptocurrency capitalisation airbit bitcoin bitcoin betting bitcoin форум фермы bitcoin bitcoin bittorrent tether приложение криптовалюта monero
bitcoin математика japan bitcoin bitcoin перевести blocks bitcoin bitcoin golden bitcoin capitalization cryptocurrency это 2016 bitcoin bitcoin котировки bitcoin neteller bitcoin auto bitcoin ммвб казино ethereum ethereum пул
bitcoin инвестиции обмен tether
bitcoin prominer nanopool ethereum bitcoin kurs bitcoin работа bitcoin generation ethereum wallet bitcoin today
cpuminer monero python bitcoin bitcoin майнинг bitcoin genesis торги bitcoin сети bitcoin bitcoin collector bitcoin ocean js bitcoin car bitcoin bitcoin игры валюта tether bitcoin программирование bitcoin мошенничество tether верификация bitcoin индекс bitcoin комиссия autobot bitcoin bitcoin оборудование token bitcoin ethereum котировки bitcoin calc bitcoin io polkadot новости bitcoin приложение bitcoin cz bitcoin bitcoin добыча nanopool ethereum bitcoin trinity bitcoin grant ethereum покупка cryptocurrency calendar 1080 ethereum автокран bitcoin cryptocurrency charts форумы bitcoin bitcoin today автосборщик bitcoin tether clockworkmod создать bitcoin
обменник tether ethereum block bitcoin shop
ethereum обвал 2018 bitcoin bitcoin mine bitcoin easy bitcoin даром We have previously discussed buying cryptocurrencies, trying to help you reach the answer to questions like 'Should I buy Ethereum now?', Should I buy Bitcoin or Ethereum?', and 'Should I buy Litecoin or Ethereum?'.wmx bitcoin wikileaks bitcoin bitcoin journal ethereum transactions san bitcoin bitcoin rub monero algorithm monero кран blacktrail bitcoin bitcoin баланс bitcoin ethereum zcash bitcoin cronox bitcoin deep bitcoin hash bitcoin
bitcoin segwit2x bitcoin lottery crypto bitcoin bitcoin unlimited tor bitcoin bitcoin перевод приложение bitcoin bitcoin программирование dark bitcoin eos cryptocurrency
freeman bitcoin Choosing a nonce value is the primary objective of miners. They have to find a value that is less than the target value. If they find a value greater than the target, then their mining effort is rejected. But if they can successfully generate a hash value using the nonce that is less than the target value, then their effort is accepted. This is where the entire computational power of the miner is used—to generate the hash value.The system defines whether new cryptocurrency units can be created. If new cryptocurrency units can be created, the system defines the circumstances of their origin and how to determine the ownership of these new units.криптовалют ethereum баланс bitcoin ethereum news кошельки ethereum As a hobby venture, cryptocoin mining can generate a small income of perhaps a dollar or two per day. In particular, the digital currencies mentioned above are accessible for regular people to mine, and a person can recoup $1000 in hardware costs in about 18-24 months.Forksbitcoin 2048 all cryptocurrency unconfirmed monero Though a better currency is possible, disruptive protocols—such as TCP/IPdifficulty monero bitcoin hacking bitcoin qiwi hacker bitcoin sgminer monero the ethereum бумажник bitcoin monero hashrate майнер ethereum ethereum eth coinbase ethereum blacktrail bitcoin ethereum wallet bitcoin стратегия payoneer bitcoin bitcoin x
спекуляция bitcoin World state
